Three judgments by Mr Justice Hayden in one case, Cheshire East Borough Council v M and others [2026] EWHC 1606 (Fam) were published today. The first is about a decision not to discharge interim care orders (ICOs) for two young teenagers; the second and the third are about whether that judgment should be published. The order refusing the application to discharge the ICOs was made in June; the other two in July and November.

We’re writing here with some brief observations on the publication issues, not the details in any media coverage to date or material on social media. We’ll follow this post up with discussion on the implications as soon as we get time.

June judgment

The ICOs for these two children were made in April by a Family Court judge, HHJ Parker, following an intensive police investigation and a raid on three properties involving 500 police and resulting in arrests of ten adults. The case is referred to in the judgments as ‘the raid on Webb House’. The local authority (LA) said there was a risk of significant harm to children, relating to allegations of modern slavery; forced marriage; inappropriate living conditions; lack of access to medical help; weapons and violence at the properties. More than 100 people appear to have been living in the three houses. The High Court judge, Hayden J, refused an application to discharge the ICOs in June because there hadn’t been enough time to fully assess all the risks, and most of the children subject to ICOs were living with family members, although parental responsibility was shared with the LA.

A total of 41 children were subject to ICOs in June, according to this judgment.

July judgment

Hayden J explained why he thought the June judgment should be published, in the usual way for High Court judgments, on The National Archives (TNA). He thought this was uncontroversial. However a mother involved in the case objected.

A transparency order (TO) had been made at the end of May, and we assume there will be reports from journalists in due course. The mother’s application had to be made on notice to the press.

The mother who objected to publication seemed to base this on the existence of the TO.  She thought the TO could be extended to postpone or prevent the publication on TNA. Hayden J explained the purpose of the TO – to allow anonymised reporting by journalists who’d attended – and that this had no effect on anonymised publication of an authorised judgment on TNA.

The mother’s legal team had also thought, incorrectly, that the TO prevented anyone from even sharing the fact that there was a care case ongoing.

After careful consideration of the case law and the competing human rights, Hayden J observed (and the mother’s lawyer accepted) that ‘the genie was out of the bottle’. Therefore:

Ultimately, Mr. Howe [for the mother] rightly focused his energy on those parts of the judgment which he submitted risked elevating the temperature of hostility surrounding Webb House for those who live or have lived there. [Para 14]

The judge explained:

Judgments handed down in the High Court in Family cases and in the Court of Protection are now usually placed on the National Archives. They are, in most cases, anonymised to protect the interests of the children or adults who lack capacity. Their purpose is to enable lawyers, other interested professionals and members of the public to inform themselves about any developments in the law. They are essentially our forensic blood supply, distributing legal information to where and to whom it is required. Without the systematic reporting of judgments, the common law’s doctrine of precedent could not operate effectively, and the coherence of our legal system would be very seriously compromised. [Para 21]

Although he was informed by the lawyers that there had been ‘tens of thousands of videos on Tic Toc’ about these families, he concluded:

… argument that even the revisiting of known facts might risk an elevation of local tension, strikes me as significantly weakened when members of the community continue to be directly engaged in debate online. This is an application to prohibit the reporting of a judgment, which is largely concerned with achieving efficient case management. The importance of that aim, alongside the wider public interest principles engaged and discussed above, tilts the balance of competing rights strongly in favour of Article 10 [para 32]

November judgment

This is supplementary to the July judgment because the judge ‘out of an abundance of caution’ had said he would allow any further submissions on the July decision. He was then surprised to receive 15 new sets of submissions arguing that his June judgment shouldn’t be published. He considered all these, but concluded they didn’t add anything to the arguments he had already heard.

All three judgments are now published on the Judiciary site although as at this afternoon, not on TNA.

Note: The numbers of individuals involved in criminal and family proceedings we have quoted here are from the judgments, and these may have since changed.